CapabilitySchwabVanguardSmartAssetFidelityRMD Answers
Basic owner RMD (one account)✓✓✓✓✓
Inherited IRA calculator✓
separate tool, beneficiary-options flow
Partial
public tool; annual-RMD years unconfirmed
✗
article only
Partial
rules page, no calculator
✓
all six regimes, one guided flow
Still-working exception inputs✗✗✗
explained in text
✗✓
Multi-account aggregation rules✗✗✗✗✓
in the one-time report
Missed-RMD penalty estimator✗✗✗✗✓
in the one-time report
Roth conversion / QCD modeling✗✗✗✗✓
in the one-time report
One-page report for your CPA✗✗✗✗✓
in the one-time report
Independent, no sales funnel✗
ends with "call us"
✗
customer-focused
✗
advisor lead-gen
✗
customer tool
✓
PriceFree (customer funnel)Free (customer funnel)Free (lead-gen)Free (customer funnel)Free calculator · one-time report in development

Tip: swipe sideways to see every column.

Fairness note. Schwab and Vanguard deserve credit, both have dedicated inherited-IRA calculators, and Schwab's beneficiary-options flow is genuinely useful. The gap isn't that they ignore inherited IRAs; it's that every one of these tools exists to acquire or retain their customers, none handles multiple accounts together, and none models penalties or trade-offs.

The four gaps, in plain English

1

"Which rules apply to me?" has no single answer elsewhere

Inherited IRA rules branch six ways based on relationship, date of death, the owner's RMD status, and your beneficiary category. Schwab splits this across tools, Vanguard doesn't confirm its calculator handles the new annual-RMD years, Fidelity has a dedicated owner-RMD calculator, but covers inherited IRAs in a rules page with no dedicated inherited calculator, and SmartAsset explains it in articles you piece together yourself. One guided flow, every regime, no account needed, that's the product.

2

Nobody models real life: multiple accounts

Everyone with a 401(k) and an IRA (which is most people) gets told to run the calculator twice and figure out aggregation themselves. IRAs aggregate, 403(b)s aggregate together, 401(k)s don't, inherited IRAs from different people don't. Getting this wrong means a missed RMD and a 25% penalty on the shortfall.

3

Nobody shows the cost of getting it wrong

Miss an RMD and the excise tax is 25% of the shortfall, 10% if you correct within two years. Not one of the big four calculators will show you that number. When the penalty is five figures on a large inherited IRA, seeing it before you act matters. Penalty modeling is part of the planned one-time report.

4

Every free calculator is a sales funnel

Schwab's pages end with "Questions? Call 800-435-4000." SmartAsset's calculator sits inside an advisor-matching funnel. Nothing wrong with that, but the tool's job includes generating advisor leads, not just your answer. An independent tool has exactly one customer: you.

Try the independent calculator
Disclaimer. Comparisons based on publicly available pages as of September 2026; features may change. RMD Answers provides estimates for educational purposes only, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Verify every result with a qualified tax professional. IRS Publication 590-B is the authoritative source for life-expectancy tables.